The response of German Naval Intelligence, at various points in World War Two, to suspicions that the Enigma cipher had been broken is well known. In 1943 the British were faced with evidence about the possible compromise of the Typex machine, the highest-level communications device in use across their armed forces. This paper compares the response of the British to the Typex scare to the German investigations concerning Enigma.
Reconstructing the story, it seems that the Germans had, in fact, read some Typex messages. Although Allied codebreaking during the war operated on a higher plane than Germany’s, it was inappropriate to assume that the Germans could not do so. Various similarities between the German and British responses emerge: the British were ill-adapted to investigating their own security; they were reluctant to chase down the truth, using arguments to justify their desire to be reassured that all was safe.
Keywords: Typex German cryptanalysis Security response TICOM
Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Historical Cryptology, HistoCrypt 2019, June 23-26, 2019, Mons, Belgium
Erskine, Ralph. 1997. The Development of Typex. Enigma Bulletin No.2 p 69-86.
Erskine, Ralph. 2002. The Admiralty and Cipher Machines during the Second World War: Not so Stupid After All. Journal of Intelligence History Vol 2 (2) p 49-68.
Ferris, John. 2005. The British “Enigma”: Britain signals security and cipher machines, 1906-1953.Chapter 3 in ‘Intelligence and Strategy – Selected Essays’. Routledge.
Hinsley, F.H., et al. 1981. British Intelligence in the Second World War, vol 2, appendix 1. Cambridge University Press.
Jackson, John. 2013. Hitler’s Codebreakers – German Signals Intelligence in World War 2. BookTower Publishing.
Mulligan, Timothy P. 1985. The German Navy Evaluates Its Cryptographic Security, October 1941. Military Affairs Vol 49 (2) p 75-79.
Ratcliff, R.A. 1999. Searching for Security: The German Investigations into Enigma’s Security in Alavarez, D. (ed.) ‘Allied and Axis Signals Intelligence in World War II’. Frank Cass, p 146-167.
Ratcliff, R.A. 2006. Delusions of Intelligence. Cambridge University Press.
Rezabek, Randy. 2017. TICOM_ the Hunt of Hitler’s Codebreakers. Privately published.
TICOM (Target Intelligence Committee). 1946. European Axis Signal Intelligence in World War II as Revealed by ’TICOM’ Investigations and by Other Prisoner of War Interrogations and Captured Material, Principally German. https://www.nsa.gov/newsfeatures/declassified-documents/european-axissigint/
Tighe, W.G.S. 1945. Review of the Security of Naval Codes and Cyphers September 1939 to May 1945. Unpublished, TNA ADM 1/27186.
Turing, Dermot. 2015. PROF: Alan Turing decoded. The History Press.