This paper describes the preliminary stage of a research project that will investigate whether the course that students take to become teachers of design and technology makes any difference to the professional identity of the teacher they become.
Design and technology (D&T) student teachers come from a wide range of backgrounds; some are young undergraduates straight from school who are acquiring subject knowledge whilst also learning to teach it. Others begin their postgraduate training having achieved subject expertise via their first degree and subsequently gained a wealth of industrial and commercial experience. Whichever route is taken; learning to teach involves not only learning the knowledge and skills required but also the formation of a professional identity as a teacher.
Like Stenberg (2010) we believe that who we are as teachers (our professional identity) is an important aspect not only of our own selves but also informs our classroom practice. According to Sachs teachers’ professional identity stands at the core of the teaching profession. It provides a framework for teachers to construct their own ideas of ’how to be’; ’how to act’ and ’how to understand’ their work and their place in society’. Teachers’ professional identity is shaped by historical and political influences as well as social and cultural ones; including the student teacher experience and context of learning to teach. It is; therefore; important to understand the impact that the teacher preparation course has on the development of student teachers’ emerging professional identity and how this might influence how (student) teachers are; act; and understand.
Our research is being undertaken in England; where teacher preparation is currently undergoing upheaval; with increasing numbers of school-based routes to qualification being proposed. We are investigating two types of teacher preparation courses; one university-based and one school-based; to find out whether these two courses have different outcomes in terms of the professional identities of the design and technology teachers and the types of teachers they are in the classroom. This may give some insight into the teachers we can expect in the future; given the Government’s change in emphasis from university-based to school-based preparation. This will have relevance for those investigating D&T student teachers’ professional identity and for those concerned with the role of the university and the role of the school in the preparation of teachers.
Keywords: Initial teacher education; PGCE; GTP; teacher professional identity
PATT 26 Conference; Technology Education in the 21st Century; Stockholm; Sweden; 26-30 June; 2012
Alsup; J. (2006) Teacher identity discourses Negotiating personal and professional spaces Mahway NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
Battey; D. & Franke; M.L. (2008) â€˜Transforming Identities: Understanding Teachers across Professional Development and Classroom Practiceâ€™ in Teacher Education Quarterly Summer 2008 127-149
Beauchamp; C. and Thomas; L. (2009) â€˜Understanding teacher identity: an overview of issues in the literature and implications for teacher educationâ€™ in Cambridge Journal of Education 39:2; 175-189
Beauchamp; C and Thomas L. (2010) Reflecting on an ideal: future teachers envision a future identityâ€™ in Reflective Practice : International and Multidisciplinary Perspectives 11 (5) pp 631-643
Beijaard; D.; Meijer; P.C. and Verloop; N. (2004) â€˜Reconsidering research on teachersâ€™ professional identityâ€™ in Teaching and Teacher Education vol 20 pp.107-128 http://www. sciencedirect.com.libezproxy.open.ac.uk/science/article/pii/S0742051X04000034 accessed 29.02.12
Carter; K. and Doyle; W.(1996) â€˜Personal narrative and life history in learning to teachâ€™ in Sikula; J.; Buttery; T.J. and Guyton; E. (eds) Handbook on Research in Teacher Education New York: Simon & Schuster Macmillan
Chong; S.; Low; E.L. and Goh; K.C. (2011) â€˜Emerging Professional Teacher Identity of Preservice Teachersâ€™ in Australian Journal of Teacher Education 36(8): 50-64
Cochran-Smith; M.; Feiman-Nemser; S.; McIntyre; D.J. (eds) (2008) Handbook of Research on Teacher Education Enduring Questions in Changing Contexts Third Edition New York: Routledge
Connelly; M. and Clandinin; J. (eds) (1999) Shaping a professional identity: Stories of educational practice New York: Teachers College Press
Day; C.; Kington; A.; Stobart; G. and Sammons; P. (2006)â€™The personal and professional selves of teachers: stable and unstable identitiesâ€™ in British Educational Research Journal 32(4): 601-616
Day; C. and Kington; A. (2008) â€˜Identity; well-being and effectiveness: the emotional contexts of teachingâ€™ in Pedagogy; Culture & Society 16(1): 7-23
DfE (2011) Training our Next Generation of Outstanding Teachers- Implementation Plan London: DfE
Erikson; E. (1968) Identity; youth; and crisis New York: WW Norton & Company
Flores; M.A. (2001) â€˜Person and context in becoming a new teacherâ€™ in Journal of Education for Teaching 27(2): 135-148
Furlong J and Sainsbury J( 2005) The Best Practice Research Scholarship Scheme; an Evaluation Research Papers in Education; 20 (1) pp. 45-83 (39)
Gratch; A. (2001) â€˜The culture of teaching and beginning teacher developmentâ€™ in Teacher Education Quarterly 28(4): 129-169
HayMcBer (2000) Research into Teacher Effectiveness: A Model of Teacher Effectiveness. Research Report no. 216. London : HMSO
Korthagen; F. (2004) â€˜In search of the essence of a good teacher: Towards a more holistic approach in teacher educationâ€™ in Teaching and Teacher Education 20; 77-97
Lauriala; A. and Kukkonen; M. (2005) â€˜Teacher and student identities as situated cognitionsâ€™ in Denicolo; P.and Kompf; M. (eds) Connecting policy and practice: Challenges for teaching and learning in schools and universities Oxford: Routledge
Lloyd; M. (2005) Beyond Identity Politics London: Sage
Lortie; D.C. (1975) School Teacher: A sociological study. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
MacGregor; D. (2009) â€˜Identity formation â€“ Influences that shape beginning teachersâ€™ professional identity â€“ Crossing the border from pre-service to in-service teacherâ€™ Paper presented at â€˜Teacher education crossing borders: Cultures; contexts; communities and curriculumâ€™ Australian Teacher Education Association; Albury; June 2009
Olsen; B. (2008) Teaching what they learn; learning what they live Boulder: Paradigm Publishers
Rodgers; C.R. and Scott; K. H. (2005) â€˜The development of the personal self and professional identity in learning to teachâ€™ in Cochran-Smith; M.; Feiman-Nemser; S. and McIntyre; D.J. (eds) Handbook of Research on Teacher Education Enduring Questions in Changing Contexts Third Edition New York: Routledge
Sachs; J. (2005) â€˜Teacher education and the development of professional identity: Learning to be a teacherâ€™ in Denicolo; P.and Kompf; M. (eds) Connecting policy and practice: Challenges for teaching and learning in schools and universities Oxford: Routledge
Stenberg; K. (2010) â€˜Identity work as a tool for promoting the professional development of student teachersâ€™ in Reflective Practice vol 11; no 3 pp331-346
Zeichner K.M. (1987) â€˜Preparing Reflective Teachers: an overview of instructional strategies which have been employed in preservice teacher educationâ€™ in The international Journal of Educational Research vol 11; no 5; pp 565-575