Article | Building National Museums in Europe 1750-2010. Conference proceedings from EuNaMus; European National Museums: Identity Politics; the Uses of the Past and the European Citizen; Bologna 28-30 April 2011. EuNaMus Report No. 1 | National museums in Cyprus: A Story of Heritage and Conflict

Title:
National museums in Cyprus: A Story of Heritage and Conflict
Author:
Alexandra Bounia: Theopisti Stylianou-Lambert:
Download:
Full text (pdf)
Year:
2011
Conference:
Building National Museums in Europe 1750-2010. Conference proceedings from EuNaMus; European National Museums: Identity Politics; the Uses of the Past and the European Citizen; Bologna 28-30 April 2011. EuNaMus Report No. 1
Issue:
064
Article no.:
009
Pages:
165-201
No. of pages:
37
Publication type:
Abstract and Fulltext
Published:
2011-09-30
Series:
Linköping Electronic Conference Proceedings
ISSN (print):
1650-3686
ISSN (online):
1650-3740
Publisher:
Linköping University Electronic Press; Linköpings universitet


Cyprus; as a former colony with a turbulent history; falls under the category of the “new emerging nation-states” (Aronsson 2011: 47). Museums are employed to construct; reinforce and project specific national narratives. Run exclusively by various ministries and the vertical bureaucratic system of decision-making that entails; these museums project a cultural policy that is unavoidably influenced by political situations. Far from being representative of universal values; the museums on both parts of this divided country focus on their territorial identities and claims. The construction of direct; strong narratives amidst political and cultural conflicts often implies silencing minority voices or voices of opposition to the prevalent narrative.

Archaeology; the discipline that brings a nation closer to its distant roots; is used to support claims on the land. The emphasis that the Greek Cypriot government and other bodies place on archaeology (majority of the museums in South Cyprus) is justified within the discourse of Hellenism and its twin pillars: antiquity and Christianity. On the other hand; the Turkish Cypriot administration places more emphasis on the historical aspect rather than the archaeological one. Its main museums focus on aspects of the Ottoman past of the island – claiming; in this sense; their share of it.

The establishment of museums in Cyprus seems to fall into three main phases: the first one extends from the last quarter of the nineteenth century until 1955; the second refers to the period between 1955 and 1974 and the third to the period after 1974. Each of these phases has its own character; which is defined by the historical events of the period; but also by the cultural preoccupations and influences Cyprus receives during this time; while it retains in the case of the two subsequent phases certain characteristics of the previous periods.

The first phase is characterized by colonial influences along with a strong wish to claim ownership of the local cultural heritage by local agents. The beginning of the interest in cultural heritage has its roots into the colonial appreciation of the Hellenic past of the island. This phase ends with the struggle against British rule starting in 1955. Due to the dominance of archaeology during this phase; the Cyprus Museum was chosen as a case study.

The second phase is characterised by the need to commemorate the struggles and suffering of both Greek and Turkish Cypriot communities. This phase starts with the struggle against British rule (1955-59) and ends with the Turkish invasion in 1974. One Greek Cypriot (the Struggle Museum) and one Turkish Cypriot museum (the Canbulat Museum) are used as case studies for this period.

Finally; the third phase is characterised by the need to preserve and promote a growing sense of national identity. At the same time; Cyprus was looking towards the west for a European future and eventually signed the accession to the EU in 2003. The State Gallery of Contemporary Art will help us demonstrate the conflicts between the old and the new.

Building National Museums in Europe 1750-2010. Conference proceedings from EuNaMus; European National Museums: Identity Politics; the Uses of the Past and the European Citizen; Bologna 28-30 April 2011. EuNaMus Report No. 1

Author:
Alexandra Bounia, Theopisti Stylianou-Lambert
Title:
National museums in Cyprus: A Story of Heritage and Conflict
References:

Aronsson; P. (2011) ‘Explaining national museums: Exploring comparative approaches to the study of national museums’; in S. Knell et all (ed.) National Museums: New Studies from Around the World; Oxon; New York: Routledge; 29-54.


Augustinos; N. (1998) ‘The protection of cultural heritage in the event of armed conflict: the Cyprus experience’; in N. Palmer (ed.) The Recovery of Stolen Art; London: Kluwer Law International; 217-260.


Azgin; B. and Papadakis; Y. (1998) ‘Foklore’; Grothusen; K.-V.; Steffani; W. and Zervakis; P. (eds) Handbooks on Southeastern Europe VIII: Cyprus; Goettingen: Vandehoek and Ruprecht.


Balandier; C. (2001) ‘Cyprus; a new archaeological frontier in the XIXth century: the struggle of European Museums for Cypriot antiquities’; in V. Tatton-Brown (ed.) Cyprus in the 19th century: Fact; Fancy and Fiction; Oxford; Oxbow Books: 3-12.


Barthel-Bouchier; D. (2010) ‘Communities of conflict: intersection of the global and the local in Cyprus’; Museum International 62(1-2): 37-41.


Bounia; A. (2010) “Museums; management of cultural heritage and local communities: the responsibility of a right”; in Tetradia Mouseiologias (Cahiers de Museologie); 7; Kaleidoskopio: Athens: 38-42 (in Greek).


Bruno; A. (1996) The Archaeological Museum of Maa in Cyprus (with an archaeological introduction by Vassos Karageorghis); Milan: Edizioni Lydra Immagine.


Constantinou; C.M. and Hatay; M. (2010) ‘Cyprus; ethnic conflict and conflicted heritage’; Ethnic and Racial Studies; 33(9): 1600-1619.


DGCULT (2004) Cultural Policy in Cyprus – National Report; prepared by the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Cyprus; Strasbourg: Council of Europe.


—— (2010) CultureWatch Europe Conference; Background Papers; Strasbourg: Council of Europe.


Coldstream; J.N. (1981) ‘Introduction to the monuments and early history of Cyprus’ in Robertson; I. (ed.) Cyprus; London and Tonbridge: Ernest Benn Limited.


—— (1982) ‘Early Iron Age’; in D. Hunt (ed.); Footprints in Cyprus; London: Trigraph Limited: 58-72.


Chroniko (2009) ‘The Swedish Archaeological Expedition in Cyprus; 1927-1931’; Newspaper Politis - Chroniko; 29 November 2009: 2-22.


Dakin; D. (1981) ‘Introduction to the later history of Cyprus’; in I. Robertson (ed.) Cyprus; London and Tonbridge: Ernest Benn Limited.


Danos; A. (2006) The Human Figure in Modern Cypriot Art: the first generations; Nicosia: Evagoras and Kathleen Lanitis Foundation.


Demetriou; Y. (2008) The Struggle Museum: a simple wandering; Nicosia: Struggle Museum (in Greek).


Department of Antiquities (yearly) Annual Report; Nicosia: Department of Antiquities. Department of Antiquities; n.d.; Official Website (http://www.mcw.gov.cy/mcw/da/da.nsf/DMLmission_en/DMLmission_en?Open Document) (last accessed 26/11/2010).


Diamantis; A. (1973) Cyprus Museum of Folk Art; Nicosia: Cyprus Museum of Folk Art (in Greek).


Dickinson G.; Blair; C. and Ott; B. (eds) (2010) Places of Public Memory; Tuscaloosa: The University of Alabama Press.


Dikaios; P. (1961) A Guide to the Cyprus Museum; 3rd edition; Nicosia: Department of Antiquities.


Eliades; I. (2008) ‘Byzantine museum: the history of its establishment’; in I. Eliades (ed.) Guide to the Byzantine Museum and Art Gallery of the Archbishop Makarios III Foundation; Nicosia: Byzantine Museum; 14-22.


Flourentzos; P. (1996) A Guide to the Larnaca District Museum; Nicosia: Department of Antiquities.


Gazi; A. (1997) ‘The Museum of Mycenaean colonization of Cyprus in Maa-Palaiokastro’; Archaeologia & Technes (Archaeology and Arts); 65: 109-112 (in Greek).


Given; M. (1998); ‘Inventing the Eteocypriots: imperialist archaeology and the manipulation of ethnic identity’; Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology; 11 (1): 3-29.


Gordon; Ch. (2004) Cultural Policy in Cyprus – European Experts’ Report; Strasbourg: Council of Europe.


Goulding; C. and Domic; D. (2009) ‘Heritage; Identity and Ideological Manipulation: The Case of Croatia’; Annals of Tourism Research; 36(1): 85-102.


Gunnis; R. (1936) Historic Cyprus; Nicosia: Rüstem.


Hadjikosti; M. (2010); Interview with the Director of the Department of Antiquities; Nicosia.


Hadjinikolaou; T. (2003) ‘Introduction’; Ethnographica; 12-13: 11-26 (in Greek).


Hamilakis; Y. (1998); ‘Archaeology and the politics of identity in Cyprus’; Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology; 11(1): 107-111.


Hill; G. (1972) A History of Cyprus; volumes 1-4; London: Cambridge University Press.


Hitchens; C. (1997) Hostage to History: Cyprus from the Ottomans to Kissinger; London: Verso.


Hunt; D. (ed.) (1982) Footprints in Cyprus; London: Trigraph Limited.


Karageorghis; V. (1982) ‘Late Bronze Age’; in D. Hunt (ed.); Footprints in Cyprus; London: Trigraph Limited; 37-56.


Karageorghis; V. (ed.) (1985a) Archaeology in Cyprus 1960-1985; Nicosia: A.G. Leventis Foundation.


—— (1985b) ‘The Cyprus Department of Antiquities; 1935-1985’; in Karageorghis; V. 1985a: 1-10.


Karageorghis; V. (2004) The A.G. Leventis Foundation and the Collections of Cypriot Antiquities in Museums Abroad; Athens: AG Leventis Foundation.


Keshishian; K.K. (1970) Everybody’s Guide to Romantic Cyprus; 13th edition; Nicosia: K.Keshishian.


Knapp; B.A. and Antoniadou S. (1998) ‘Archaeology; politics and the cultural heritage of Cyprus’; in L. Meskel (ed.) Archaeology under fire; Nationalism; politics and heritage in Eastern Mediterranean; London: Routledge; 13- 41.


Koudounaris; A. (1993) ‘The Pierides Family’; in Kathimerini; Seven Days; Sunday 31st October: 3-4 (in Greek).


Kyriacou; G. (2011) Interview; Cultural Officer of the Ministry of Culture and Education (1969 to 1976); Nicosia.


Leriou; A.; (2007) ‘The Hellenisation of Cyprus: tracing its beginnings (an updated version)’; in S. Müller Celca and J.-C. David; Patrimoines culturels en Méditerranée orientale: recherché scientifique et enjeux identitaires. 1er atelier (29 Nov. 2007): Chypre; une stratigraphie de l’ identité. Recontres scientifiques en ligne de la Maison de l ‘ Orient et de la Mediterranée; Lyon.


Mallinson; W. (2005) Cyprus: A Modern History; London: L. B. Tauris.


Merrillees; R.S. (2005) The First Cyprus Museum in Victoria Street; Nicosia; Nicosia: Moufflon Publications.


Michalopoulos; A. (2004) The Museums of Cyprus; Athens: Erevnites.


Most; G. (2008) ‘Philellenism; cosmopolitanism; nationalism’; in Zacharia; K. (ed.) Hellenisms. Culture; Identity and Ethnicity from Antiquity to Modernity; London: Ashgate Variorum; 151-167.


Myres; J.L. and Ohneflasch-Richter; M. (1899) A Catalogue of the Cyprus Museum; Oxford: Clarendon Press.


Nikita; E. (1997) The Art Movement in Cyprus from the beginning of our century until the Liberation; Nicosia: Ministry of Education and Culture (in Greek).


—— (1998) ‘Contemporary Cypriot Art: Points of reference’; in E. Nikita (ed.) State Gallery of Contemporary Cypriot Art; Nicosia: Ministry of Education and Culture; 14-31


—— (2009) ‘Cypriot Art 1950-1980 Spacial-temporal Context Towards a New Reading’; in A. Michael (ed.) Discourse with Contemporary Trends in Art and the Quest for Identity; Nicosia: Evagoras and Kathleen Lanitis Foundation; 13-19.


—— (2011) Interview (Cultural Officer of the Ministry of Education and Culture (1977- 2009); Nicosia.


Nicolaou; I. (2003) Research regarding the storage conditions and keeping of artworks belonging to the Cultural Services of the Ministry of Education and Culture (in Greek); Nicosia: the office of the commissioner for administration (ombudsman).


Papachrysostomou; Ch. (1977) Guide of the National Struggle Museum. Its Collections and its National Importance; Nicosia: National Struggle Museum (in Greek).


Papadakis; Y. (1994) ‘The National Struggle Museums of a divided city’; Ethnic and Racial Studies; 17(3): 400-419.


Paraskevas; P. (2010) Interview (Director of the Cultural Services of the Ministry of Education and Culture); Nicosia.


Parker; R. (ed.) (1972) Aphrodite’s Realm: An illustrated guide and handbook to Cyprus; Nicosia: Zavallis Press.


Peltenburg; E.J. (1982) ‘Neolithic to late Bronze Age’; in D. Hunt (ed.) Footprints in Cyprus; London: Trigraph Limited; 18-36.


Pilides; D. (2009) George Jeffery: His Diaries and the Ancient Monuments of Cyprus; vols. 1 &2; Nicosia: Department of Antiquities.


Plantzos; D. and Damaskos; D. (eds) (2008) A Singular Antiquity: Archaeology and hellenic identity in twentieth-century Greece; Mouseio Benaki 3rd Supplement; Athens: Benaki Museum.


Public Relations Department TRNC (n.d.)The Museum of National Struggle; Nicosia.


Runciman; S. (1982) ‘The Byzantine Period’; in D. Hunt (ed.) Footprints in Cyprus; London: Trigraph Limited; 134-162.


Rizopoulou-Egumenidou; E. (1991) The House of the Dragoman of Cyprus Hadjigeorgakis Kornesios; Nicosia: Bank of Cyprus Cultural Foundation.


Rizopoulou-Egumenidou; E. (1993) ‘The Dragoman of Cyprus Hadjigeorgakis Kornesios’; in The Royal Danish Academy of Fine Arts; A Dragoman’s House: The house of Hadjigeorgakis Kornesios in Nicosia. A Study of Background and Architecture; Nicosia: School of Architecture Publishers – Cyprus Museum; 10-16.


—— (1995) The Dragoman Hadjigeorgakis Kornesios and his era; Nicosia: A.G. Leventis Foundation (in Greek).


Rizopoulou-Egumenidou; E. and Phiouri. E. (2008) ‘The Museum of Folk Art’; in Municipality of Yeroskipou (ed.) Yeroskipou: from antiquity until today; Municipality of Yeroskipou: Nicosia; 217-254 (in Greek).


Rystedt; E. (ed.) (1994) Swedish Cyprus Expedition: The Living Past; Stockholm: Medelhavsmuseet.


Sandell; R. (2007) Museums; Prejudice and the Reframing of Difference. London; New York: Routledge.


Sant Cassia; P. (1998) ‘Commentary on Given’; Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology; 11(1): 123-124.


Schiza; M. (1997) ‘Culture in a package’; Phileleftheros Newspaper; 23/02/1997: 8-9 (in Greek).


Schiza; M. (1999) ‘Cultural Co-operation with Greece’; Phileleftheros Newspaper; 05/10/1999 (in Greek).


Scott; J. (2002a) ‘Mapping the past: Turkish Cypriot narratives of time and place in the Canbulat Museum’; Northern Cyprus”; History and Anthropology; 13(3): 217-230.


—— (2002b) ‘World heritage as a model for citizenship: the case of Cyprus’; International Journal of Heritage Studies; 8(2): 99-115.


Shaw; W.M.K. (2003) Possessors and Possessed: Museums; Archaeology and the Visualization of History in the Late Ottoman Empire; Berkeley: University of California Press.


Silberman; N.A. (1998) ‘Playing with matches’; Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology; 11(1): 113-116.


Stanley-Price; N. (2001) ‘The Ottoman Law of Antiquities (1874) and the founding of the Cyprus Museum’; in V. Tatton-Brown (ed.) Cyprus in the 19th century: Fact; Fancy and Fiction; Oxford: Oxbow Books; 267-275.


State Collection of Contemporary Cypriot Art (1980) Kratiki Syllogi Sychronis Technis. Nicosia: Ministry of Education.


Stylianou; P. (1987) The Plundering of Cultural Heritage in Occupied Cyprus; Nicosia: Nicosia Library.


Stylianou; P. and Demetriou; Y. (1991) Guide to the Struggle Museum: The reasons that led to the two revolutionary movements in 1931 and 1955; Nicosia: Struggle Museum (in Greek).


Tatton-Brown; V.A. (1982) ‘The Archaic Period’; ‘The Classical Period’; ‘The Hellenistic Period’; in D. Hunt (ed.) Footprints in Cyprus; London: Trigraph Limited; 73-105.


Tenekides; G. (1994) ‘The rescue of the cultural heritage of occupied Cyprus. The international dimensions’; in Cyprus: The Plundering of a 9000-year-old Civilization; Athens: Committee for the Protections of the Cultural Heritage of Cyprus.


Toumazis; Y. (2010) ‘Pride and prejudice. Photography and memory in Cyprus’; in 1s t International Conference of Photography and Theory: Cypriot Photography in Context: Time; Place and Identity; Conference Proceedings; 26-28 Nov.; Limassol; Cyprus University of Technology; available electronically.


TRNC Public Relations Department (n.d.); The Museum of National Struggle; Lefkosia (in English and Turkish).


TRNC Department of Antiquities and Museums (n.d.) Official Website (http://www.cypnet.co.uk/ncyprus/culture/institutions/mz-antiquities.htm) (accessed 26/11/2010)


Van Dommelen; P. (1998) ‘Between academic doubt and political involvement’; Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology; 11(1): 117-121.


Williams; P. (2007) Memorial Museums: The Global Rush to Commemorate Atrocities; Oxford; New York: Berg.


Wright; G.R.H. (2001) ‘Archaeology and the Islamic law in Ottoman Cyprus;’ in V. Tatton-Brown (ed.) Cyprus in the 19th century: Fact; Fancy and Fiction; Oxbow Books; 261-266.

Building National Museums in Europe 1750-2010. Conference proceedings from EuNaMus; European National Museums: Identity Politics; the Uses of the Past and the European Citizen; Bologna 28-30 April 2011. EuNaMus Report No. 1

Author:
Alexandra Bounia, Theopisti Stylianou-Lambert
Title:
National museums in Cyprus: A Story of Heritage and Conflict
Note: the following are taken directly from CrossRef
Citations:
No citations available at the moment