Article | Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008 | Thinking through the "Other": Comparing Representations of Cultural Alterity at the British Museum and the Shanghai Museum

Title:
Thinking through the "Other": Comparing Representations of Cultural Alterity at the British Museum and the Shanghai Museum
Author:
Marzia Varutti: Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies (IHEID), Geneva, Switzerland
Download:
Full text (pdf)
Year:
2008
Conference:
Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008
Issue:
030
Article no.:
020
Pages:
263-278
No. of pages:
14
Publication type:
Abstract and Fulltext
Published:
2008-05-20
Series:
Linköping Electronic Conference Proceedings
ISSN (print):
1650-3686
ISSN (online):
1650-3740
Publisher:
Linköping University Electronic Press; Linköpings universitet


In this paper; I wish to analyse and compare the process through which cultural diversity is constructed and represented in national museums in the UK and in China.

I contend that the museum representation of alterity reflects not only specific culturally and historically determined configurations of the political; social and economic spheres; but also; and more to the point; contemporary processes of change in the perception of the past; the organisation of knowledge and systems of value. As case studies; I will consider the British Museum and the Shanghai Museum.

I want to ask: who is the “Other”? What forces; ratio and intellectual stances implicitly inform its museum representation? What is the role of the colonial experience (as a colonizer in one case and as a colonized in the other) in shaping the representation of alterity?

I show that the Shanghai Museum and the British Museum offer two quite different paradigms of representation of the “Other”. In the case of the Shanghai Museum; I maintain that the “Other” is represented by Chinese ethnic minorities. Conversely; I argue that in the British Museum the category of “Other” is multiple and open – indeed; the “Other” is everywhere; scattered in the different museum sections in a confusion of museological and disciplinary approaches. Aiming at making explicit and discussing the curatorial decisions informing the representation of alterity; the comparison will focus on the organisation of the collections; the selection of objects; the display techniques; as well as the amount and quality of information supplied by exhibitions.

The investigation confirms that the differences between the two paradigms are the result of different historical and cultural trajectories. Yet; I want to argue that these two differing approaches may also be understood as responses to different challenges: of inclusion and national cohesion in the case of Shanghai Museum; and of distancing from the colonial past in the case of the British Museum. In this sense; the representations of alterity in the two museums share a major feature: a generalized emphasis on the past and on aesthetics. I hold that the historicisation and aesthetisation of the “Other” are strategies to elude engagement with politically or socially delicate issues that might threaten domestic social cohesion and/or the harmony of international relations.

“The challenge now is to reinvent the museum as an institution that can orchestrate new relations and perceptions of difference that both break free from the hierarchically organized forms of stigmatic othering that characterized the exhibitionary complex and provide more socially invigorating and; from a civic perspective; more beneficial interfaces between different cultures” (Bennett; 2006:59)

Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008

Author:
Marzia Varutti
Title:
Thinking through the "Other": Comparing Representations of Cultural Alterity at the British Museum and the Shanghai Museum
References:

Bennet; Tony; 2006; “Exhibition; difference and the logic of culture”; Karp; Ivan; Kratz; Corinne A.; Szwaja; Lynn; Ybarra-Frausto; Tomás; Museum Frictions. Public cultures/global transformations; Duke University Press; London.


Bouquet; Mary; 2001; “Streetwise in Museumland”; Folk; 43; pp.77–101.


Clifford; James; 1988; The predicament of culture; Twentieth-century ethnography; literature and art; Cambridge; MA:Harvald University Press.


Clunas Craig; 1997; “Oriental Antiquities/Far Eastern Art”; Barlow; Tani E.; Formations of colonial modernity in East Asia; Duke University Press; pp.413–446.


Dahl; G. B.; Stade; Ronald; 2000; «Anthropology; museums; museums and contemporary cultural processes: an introduction”; Ethnos; 65; 2; pp.157–171.


Doran; Valerie C.; 1997; “The New Shanghai Museum: An Introduction and Interview with the Directors”; Orientations; May issue.


Fei; Xiaotong; 1979; Modernisation and national minorities i China; Occasional Papers n.6; Centre for East Asian Studies; McGill University; Montreal.


Fiskesjö; Magnus; 2007; “The trouble with world culture. Recent museum developments in Sweden”; Anthropology Today; 23; pp.6–11.


Friedman; Jonathan; 2001; “Museums; the State and global transformation”; Folk; 43; pp.251–257.


Gladney; Dru; 1994; "Representing nationality in China: reconfiguring majority/minority identities"; Journal of Asian studies; 53;1; pp.92–123.


Jonsson; Hjorleifur; 2000; “Yao minority identity and the location of difference in the South China borderlands”; Ethnos; 65; 1; pp. 56–82.


Miller; Daniel; 1991; “Primitive art and the necessity of primitivism to art”; HILLER SUSAN; The myth of primitivism; Perspectives on art; London; Routledge; p.50–71


Naguib; Saphinaz-Amal; 2004; “The aesthetics of otherness in Museums of Cultural History”; Tidsskrift for Kulturforskning; 3; 4; pp.5–21.


Shelton; Anthony; 2001; “Museums in an age of cultural hybridity”; Folk; 43; p.221–250.


Spring; Christopher; Barley; Nigel; Hudson; Julie; 2001; “The Sainsbury African Galleries at the British Museum”; African Arts; 34; 3; pp. 18-37+93.


Wallis Brian; 1991; “ Selling Nations”; Art In America; September; 142; pp.85–91.


Wei; Liu Wei; Kolbas; Judith; 2007; A Study of the North China Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society; by Wang Yi [review]; Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society; 17;1; pp.79–80.


Wilson; David (ed.); 2001; The collections of the British Museum; The British Museum Press.

Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008

Author:
Marzia Varutti
Title:
Thinking through the "Other": Comparing Representations of Cultural Alterity at the British Museum and the Shanghai Museum
Note: the following are taken directly from CrossRef
Citations:
No citations available at the moment