Article | Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008 | Appropriations of Antiquity: A Diachronic Comparison of Museums and Scholarship

Title:
Appropriations of Antiquity: A Diachronic Comparison of Museums and Scholarship
Author:
Johannes Siapkas: Uppsala University, Sweden Lena Sjögren: Stockholm University, Sweden
Download:
Full text (pdf)
Year:
2008
Conference:
Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008
Issue:
030
Article no.:
016
Pages:
205-223
No. of pages:
19
Publication type:
Abstract and Fulltext
Published:
2008-05-20
Series:
Linköping Electronic Conference Proceedings
ISSN (print):
1650-3686
ISSN (online):
1650-3740
Publisher:
Linköping University Electronic Press; Linköpings universitet


Export in BibTex, RIS or text

Sculpture from ancient Greece and Rome is an emblematic category of high art in the western museum tradition. Accordingly; displays of ancient sculpture in museums form an instructive case study for a wide-reaching; comparative analysis of museological developments from the 18th century and onwards. Isolating a category of exhibited objects like ancient sculptures is fruitful for a comparative approach because it transcends national traditions. It is hard to pinpoint differences in displays of ancient sculptures that can be attributed to; or explained by; national traditions. The appropriation of the classical legacy in various national traditions should not be viewed as an excluding facet of a unique national identity; but is often better understood as an inclusive part of the national identity since it signals that the specific nation belongs within a wide cultural sphere. In contrast; our empirical examples suggest that there are closer similarities between the theoretical developments in academia and museums. In this paper; therefore; we aim to elaborate on the chronological development of sculpture exhibitions and identify the discursive foundations that scholarship and museum exhibitions share. Drawing on this; it can tentatively be concluded the development of displays of ancient sculpture is associated closer to the development in academia than to national museological traditions. From our perspective; museums can be viewed as an integrated part of the institutions of knowledge.

Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008

Author:
Johannes Siapkas, Lena Sjögren
Title:
Appropriations of Antiquity: A Diachronic Comparison of Museums and Scholarship
References:

Albertoni; Margherita et al. 2006. The Capitoline Museums: Guide. Milan & Rome.


Barkan; Leonard. Unearthing the Past: Archaeology and Aesthetics in Renaissance Culture. (New Haven & London 1999).


Bazin; Germain. The Museum Age. (New York 1967).


Beard; Mary. “Cast: Between art and science”; in Henri Lavagne and Francois Queyrel (eds.); Les moulages de sculptures antiques et l’histoire de l’archĂ©ologie: actes du colloque international; Paris; 24 octobre 1997; (Geneva 2000); 157-166.


Beck; Herbert and Peter C. Bol (eds.). Polykletforschung (Schriften des Liebieghauses). (Berlin 1993)


Bennett; Tony. The birth of the Museum: History; theory; politics. (London 1995).


Bjurström; Per. “Physiocratic Ideals and National Galleries”; in Per Bjurström (ed.); The Genesis of the Art Museum in the 18th Century: Papers given at a Symposium in Nationalmuseum Stockholm; June 26; 1992; in cooperation with the Royal Academy of Letters; History and Antiquities; (Stockholm 1993); p. 28-60.


Boardman; John and David Finn. The Parthenon and Its Sculptures. (London 1985).


Clark; Anthony M. 1966-67. “The development of the collections and museums of 18th century Rome”; Art Journal 26; 1966-68; p. 136-143.


Connor; Peter. “Cast-collecting in the Nineteenth Century: Scholarship; Aesthetics; Connoisseurship”; in Graeme W. Clarke and John C. Eade (eds.). Rediscovering Hellenism: The Hellenic Inheritance and the English Imagination; (Cambridge 1998); p. 187-235.


Corso; Antonio. The art of Praxiteles: the development of Praxiteles’ workshop and its cultural tradition until the sculptor’s acme (364-1BC) (Studia archaeologica; 133). (Roma 2004)


Crimp; D. “The postmodern museum”; Parachute (March-May 1987).


Crowther; David. 1989. “Archaeology; material culture and museums”; in Susan M. Pearce (ed.); Museum Studies in Material Culture; (London 1989); p. 35-46.


De Angelis; M. A. “Il "Braccio Nuovo" del Museo Chiaramonti: un prototipi di museo tra passato e future”; Bollettino - Monumenti musei e gallerie pontificie 14; 1994; p. 184-256.


Diebold; William J. “The Politics of Derestoration: The Aegina Pediments and the German Confrontation with the Past”; Art Journal 54 (2); 1995; p. 60-66.


Dillon; Sheila. “Subject selection and viewer reception of Greek portraits from Herculaneum and Tivoli”; Journal of Roman Archaeology 13; 2000; p. 21-40.


Ehrhardt; Wolfgang. Das Akademische Kunstmuseum der Universität Bonn under der Direktion von Friedrich Gottlieb Welcker und Otto Jahn. (Opladen 1982).


Fentress; Elizabeth. “Around the temple. The new galleries of the Capitoline Museum”; American Journal of Archaeology 111; 2007; p. 365-369.


Fitzpatrick Nichols M. “Plaster cast sculpture: A history of touch”; Archaeological Review from Cambridge 21 (2); 2006; p. 114-130.


Furtwängler; Adolf. Meisterwerke der griechischen Plastik: Kunstgeschichtliche Untersuchungen. (Leipzig; Berlin 1893).


Gazda; Elaine. “Beyond copying: Artistic originality and tradition”; in Elaine Gazda (ed.); The Ancient Art of emulation. Studies in artistic originality and tradition from the Present to Classical Antiquity; (Ann Arbor 2002); p. 1-24.


Gazi; Andromache. “The Museum of casts in Athens (1846-1874)”; Journal of the History of Collections 10 (1); 1998; p. 87-91.


Gregory; A. P. “Powerful images. Responses to portraits and the political uses of images in Rome”; Journal of Roman Archaeology 7; 1994; p. 80-99.


Gropplero di Troppenburg; Elianna. “Die Innenaustattung der Glyptothek durch Leo von Klenze”; in Klaus Vierneisel and Gottlieb Leinz (eds.); Glyptothek München 1830-1980: Jubiläumsaustellung zur Entstehungs- und Baugeschichte. 17 September bis 23 November 1980; (München 1980); p. 190-213.


Hamdorf; Friedrich Wilhelm. 1992. “Du "theatrum mundi" Ă  la glorification des ducs de Bavière: Remarques sur les collections d’antiques Ă  Munich; du XVIe au XVIIIe siècle”; in A.-F. Laurens and Krzysztof Pomian (eds.); L’Anticomanie: la collection d’antiquitĂ©s aux 18e et 19e siècles; (Paris 1992); p. 39-48.


Harris; Jonathan. The New Art History. (London & New York 2001).


Haskell; Frances and Nicholas Penny. Taste and the Antique. The lure of Classical sculpture 1500-1900. (New Haven & London 1981).


Helmberger; Werner and Raimund WĂĽnsche (eds.). Das Pompejanum in Aschaffenburg. (MĂĽnchen 2006).


Hooper-Greenhill; Eilean. “The museum in the disciplinary society”; in Susan M. Pearce (ed.); Museum Studies in Material Culture; (London 1989); p. 61-72.


Höcker; Christoph and Lambert Schneider. Phidias. (Hamburg 1993).


Hölscher; Tonio. The Language of Images in Roman Art: Art as a semantic system in the Roman world. Translated by A. Snodgrass and A.


nzl-Snodgrass. (Cambridge 2003). Original edition; Römische Bildsprache als semantisches System. (Heidelberg 1987).


Jenkins; Ian. Archaeologists and aesthetes in the sculpture galleries of the British Museum 1800-1939. (London 1992).


Knell; Heiner and Hanno-Walter Kruft. “Re-Opening of the Munich Glyptothek”; The Burlington Magazine 114 (831); 1972; p. 431-436.


Kontrarou-Rassia; N. 2007. Elate na stisoume to Neo Mouseio Akropolis. Eleutherotypia; 070924.


Kreikenbom; Detlev. Bildwerke nach Polyklet; Kopienkritische Untersuchungen zu den männlichen statuarischen Typen nach polykletischen Vorbildern. (Berlin 1990).


La Regina; Adriano (ed.). Museo Nazionale Romano. Palazzo Massimo alle Terme; Baths of Diocletian; Palazzo Altemps; Palatine Museum; Crypta Balbi. (Rome 2005).


Lowenthal; David. The Past is a Foreign Country. (Cambridge 1985).


Maass; Michael. “Nachträgliche Überlegungen zur Restaurierung der Ägineten”; Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts: Athenische Abteilung 1984; p.165-176.


Maleuvre; Didier. Museum Memories: History; Technology; Art; Cultural Memory in the Present. (Stanford 1999).


Marchand; Suzanne L. Down from Olympus: Archaeology and Philhellenism in Germany; 1750-1970. (Princeton 1996).


cClellan; Andrew. Inventing the Louvre: Art; politics; and the origins of the modern museum in eighteenth-century Paris. (New York 1994).


Morris; Ian. Archaeology as Cultural History: Words and Things in Iron Age Greece. (Malden 2000)


Neils; Jenifer. The Parthenon Frieze. (Cambridge 2001).


Nelson; Robert S. “The Slide Lecture; or The Work of Art History in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction”; Critical Inquiry 26 (3); 2000; p. 414-434. Newhouse; Victoria. Art and the Power of Placement. (New York 2005).


Palagia; Olga and Jerome J. Pollitt (eds.). Personal styles in Greek sculpture; (Yale Classical studies; 30). (Cambridge 1996).


Perry; Ellen. The Aesthetics of emulation in the visual arts of ancient Rome. (Cambridge 2005).


Pietrangeli; Carlo. The Vatican Museums: Five centuries of history. Translated by P. Spring. (Rome 1993).


Pomian; Krzysztof. Collectors and curiosities: Paris and Venice; 1500-1800. Translated by E. Wiles-Portier. (Cambridge 1990).


Potts; Alex. “Die Skulpturenaufstellung in der Glyptothek”; in Klaus Vierneisel and Gottlieb Leinz (eds.); Glyptothek München 1830-1980: Jubiläumsaustellung zur Entstehungs- und Baugeschichte. 17 September bis 23 November 1980; (München 1980); p. 258-283.


Potts; Alex. Flesh and the ideal: Winckelmann and the origins of art history. (New Haven 1994).


Potts; Alex. 2006. “Introduction” in Johann Joachim Winckelmann; History of the Art of Antiquity. Translated by H. F. Mallgrave. (Los Angeles 2006); p. xx-xx.


Preziosi; Donald. Rethinking Art History: Meditations on a coy science. (New Haven & London 1989).


Rees; A. L.; and Frances Borzello (eds.) The New Art History. (London 1986).


Ridgway; Brunhilde Sismondo. The Severe Style in Greek Sculpture. (Princeton 1970).


Ridgway; Brunhilde Sismondo. Fifth-century styles in Greek sculpture. (Princeton 1981).


Ridgway; Brunhilde Sismondo. Hellenistic sculpture. (Bristol 1990-2002).


Ridgway; Brunhilde Sismondo. The archaic style in Greek sculpture. 2nd ed. (Chicago 1993).


Ridgway; Brunhilde Sismondo. Fourth-century styles in Greek sculpture; Wisconsin studies in classics. (Madison 1997).


Ridgway; Brunhilde Sismondo. “The state of research on Ancient Art”; Art Bulletin 68 (1); 1986; p. 7-23.


Robertson; Martin. A History of Greek Art. 2 vols. (Cambridge 1975).


Siapkas; Johannes; and Lena Sjögren. “Ancient Sculptures and National Museums: Universal and Local Claims of Antiquity”; in P. Aronsson and M. Hillström (eds.); NaMu; Making National Museums Program; Setting the Frames; 26-28 February; Norrköping; Sweden; (Linköping University Electronic Press; 22; 2007); p. 153-163. Available from http://www.ep.liu.se/ecp/022/014/ecp072214.pdf.


Spinola; G. Il Museo Pio Clementino I; Guide Cataloghi Musei Vaticani; 3. (CittĂ  del Vaticano 1996).


Stewart; Andrew. Skopas of Paros. (Park Ridge; N.J. 1977).


Stewart; Andrew. Greek sculpture: an exploration. (New Haven 1990).


Symeonoglou; Sarantis. “A new analysis of the Parthenon frieze”; in Michael B. Cosmopoulos (ed.); The Parthenon and its sculptures; edited by M. Cosmopoulos. (Cambridge 2004); p. 5-42.


Tanner; Jeremy. “Portraits; power; and patronage in the Late Roman Republic”; Journal of Roman Studies; 90; 2000; p. 18-50.


Todisco; Luigi. Scultura Greca del iv Secolo. Maestri e Scuole di statuaria tra ClassicitĂ  ed Ellenismo. (Milano 1993).


Wallach; Alan. “The American Cast Museum: An Episode in the History of the Institutional Definition of Art”; in Alan Wallach; Exhibiting contradiction. Essays on the Art Museum in the United States; (Amherst; Mass. 1998); p. 38-56.


Vermeule; Cornelius. C. Greek sculpture and Roman taste. The purpose and setting of Graeco-Roman art in Italy and the Greek Imperial East. (Ann Arbor 1977).


Whitehill; Walter Muir. Museum of Fine Arts Boston: A Centennial History. 2 vols. (Cambridge; Mass. 1970).


Vickers; Michael. “Greek and Roman Antiquities in the seventeenth century”; in Oliver Impey and Arthur MacGregor (eds.); The origins of the Museum. The cabinet of curiosities in sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Europe; (Oxford 1985); p. 309-318.


Winckelmann; Johann Joachim. History of art of antiquity. Translated by H. F. Mallgrave. (Los Angeles 2006).


Zanker; Paul. Klassizistische Statuen: Studien zur Veränderung des Kunstgeschmacks in der römischen Kaiserzeit. (Mainz 1974).


Zanker; Paul. The power of images in the Age of Augustus. (Ann Arbor 1988).

Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008

Author:
Johannes Siapkas, Lena Sjögren
Title:
Appropriations of Antiquity: A Diachronic Comparison of Museums and Scholarship
Note: the following are taken directly from CrossRef
Citations:
No citations available at the moment