Article | Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008 | National Museums and the Legacies of Exclusion. Issues and Challenges Around Change in the 21st Century
Göm menyn

Title:
National Museums and the Legacies of Exclusion. Issues and Challenges Around Change in the 21st Century
Author:
Cristina Lleras: Museum Studies, University of Leicester, UK/ Art and History Curator, Museo Nacional de Colombia, Colombia
Download:
Full text (pdf)
Year:
2008
Conference:
Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008
Issue:
030
Article no.:
021
Pages:
279-300
No. of pages:
22
Publication type:
Abstract and Fulltext
Published:
2008-05-20
Series:
Linköping Electronic Conference Proceedings
ISSN (print):
1650-3686
ISSN (online):
1650-3740
Publisher:
Linköping University Electronic Press; Linköpings universitet


Export in BibTex, RIS or text

The perpetual crisis of national museums is directly related to the character of the nation that has been considered ‚Äď since the latter half of the 20th century ‚Äď as elusive; fluid; constructed and difficult to grasp. How have national museums reacted; supported; resisted or rejected political changes of the nation? What were the privileged representations of the Nation-state? And what are the ways in which these institutions are trying to come to grips with multicultural and multiethnic societies? In an attempt to shed light on these questions; this essay is constructed around the tensions and challenges that face national museums as they aim to represent both a fragmented and united community with the pressures to overcompensate past exclusions.

In order to look at how national museums have responded to their contexts; and the role they are playing today; the paper will examine the case of the Museo Nacional de Colombia. This Latin American country has; in the last fifteen years; advanced greatly in terms of developing a legislation that recognizes the existence of multiple ethnicities and cultures in opposition of the well-known project of homogenization that characterized the Nation-state. Nevertheless; the reality of the communities is complex and though symbolically the 1991 Constitution has had great impact; there has been a backlash in terms of overcoming discrimination; poverty and improvement of the living conditions of marginalized groups. What then; is the role of the museum in this changed setting?

Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008

Author:
Cristina Lleras
Title:
National Museums and the Legacies of Exclusion. Issues and Challenges Around Change in the 21st Century
References:

Achugar; H.; 2002. ‚ÄúEnsayo sobre la naci√≥n a comienzos del siglo XXI‚ÄĚ in Imaginarios de naci√≥n. Pensar en medio de la tormenta; coord. J. Mart√≠n-Barbero; Ministerio de Cultura; Bogot√°.


Almario; O.; 2007. ‚ÄúReparaciones contempor√°neas: de la Memoria de la Esclavitud al cuestionamiento de la exclusi√≥n social y el racismo‚ÄĚ in Afro-reparaciones: memorias de la esclavitud y justicia reparativa para negros; afrocolombianos y raizales; eds. C. Mosquera & L. C.


rcelos; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Arocha; J.; 2004. ‚ÄúLey 70 de 1993: utop√≠a para afrodescencientes excluidos‚ÄĚ in Utop√≠a para los excluidos. El multiculturalismo en √Āfrica y Am√©rica Latina; comp. J. Arocha; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Arocha; J; & Moreno; L. M.; 2007. ‚ÄúAndinocentrismo; salvajismo y afro-reparaciones‚ÄĚ in Afro-reparaciones: memorias de la esclavitud y justicia reparativa para negros; afrocolombianos y raizales; eds. C. Mosquera & L. C. Barcelos; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Ashley; S.; 2005. State Authority and the Public Sphere: Ideas on the Changing Role of the Museum as a Canadian Social Institution. Museum and Society; 3(1); 5‚Äď17.


Bol√≠var; I. J.; 2002. ‚ÄúLa construcci√≥n de la naci√≥n y la transformaci√≥n de lo pol√≠tico‚ÄĚ in Naci√≥n y sociedad contempor√°nea; coord. I. J. Bol√≠var; G. Ferro & A. D√°vila; Ministerio de Cultura; Bogot√°.


Calder√≥n; A. M.; 2004. ‚ÄúAfrocolombianos en el Museo Nacional de Colombia: Sala Nuevo Reino de Granada 1550‚Äď1810‚ÄĚ; unpublished document; Museo Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Clifford; J.; 1999. ‚ÄúMuseums as contact zones‚ÄĚ in Representing the Nation: A Reader; eds. D. Boswell and J. Evans; Routledge; London; New York.


Crooke; E.; 2005. ‚ÄúMuseums; Communities and the Politics of Heritage in Northern Ireland‚ÄĚ in The Politics of Heritage; The Legacies of Race; ed. J. Littler; & R. Naidoo; Routledge; Oxon; New York.


Dean; D. & Rider; P.; 2005. Museums; Nation and Political History in the Australian National Museum and the Canadian Museum of Civilization. Museum and Society; 3(1); 35‚Äď50.


Dibley; B.; 2005. The museum‚Äôs redemption: Contact zones; government and the limits of reform. International Journal of Cultural Studies; 8(5); 5‚Äď27.


Dyson; L.; 2005. ‚ÄúReinventing the Nation. British Heritage and the Bicultural Settlement in New Zealand‚ÄĚ in The Politics of Heritage; The Legacies of Race; ed. J. Littler; & R. Naidoo; Routledge; Oxon; New York.


Gardner; J.; 2004. Contested Terrain: History; Museums and the Public. The Public Historian; 26 (4); 11‚Äď21.


G√≥mez; T.; 2004. ‚ÄúLugares de memoria e identidad nacional en Colombia‚ÄĚ in Utop√≠a para los excluidos. El multiculturalismo en √Āfrica y Am√©rica Latina; comp. J. Arocha; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Gonz√°lez; J. E.; 2007. ‚ÄúIntroducci√≥n‚ÄĚ in Naci√≥n y nacionalismo en Am√©rica Latina; ed. J. E. Gonz√°lez; Consejo Latinoamericano de Ciencias Sociales/ Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Gros; C.; 2004. ‚Äú¬ŅCu√°l autonom√≠a para los pueblos ind√≠genas de Am√©rica Latina?‚ÄĚ in Utop√≠a para los excluidos. El multiculturalismo en √Āfrica y Am√©rica Latina; comp. J. Arocha; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Gros; C.; 2000. ‚ÄúDe la naci√≥n mestiza a la naci√≥n plural: el nuevo discurso de las identidades en el contexto de la globalizaci√≥n‚ÄĚ in Museo; memoria y naci√≥n. Misi√≥n de los museos nacionales para los ciudadanos del futuro; comp. G. S√°nchez & M. E. Wills; Ministerio de Cultura; Bogot√°.


Hall; S.; 1999. ‚ÄúCulture; community; nation‚ÄĚ in Representing the Nation: A Reader; eds. D. Boswell and J. Evans; Routledge; London; New York.


Hall; S.; 2005. ‚ÄúWhose Heritage? Un-settling The Heritage; Re-imaging the Post-Nation‚ÄĚ in The Politics of Heritage; The Legacies of Race; ed. J. Littler; & R. Naidoo; Routledge; Oxon; New York.


Helg; A.; 2004. ‚ÄúConstituciones y pr√°cticas sociopol√≠ticas de las minor√≠as de origen africano: una comparaci√≥n entre Colombia y Cuba‚ÄĚ in Utop√≠a para los excluidos. El multiculturalismo en √Āfrica y Am√©rica Latina; comp. J. Arocha; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Hopper-Greenhill; E.; 2000. Museums and the Interpretation of Culture; Routledge; New York/ Oxon.


Jordan; G. & Weedon; C.; 1995. Cultural Politics. Class; Gender; Race and the Postmodern World; Blackwell; Cambridge/ Oxford.


Kohl; P.; 1998. Nationalism and Archaeology: On the Constructions of Nations and the Reconstructions of the Remote past. Annual Review of Anthropology; 27; 223‚Äď246.


Lao-Montes; A.; 2007. ‚ÄúSin justicia √©tnico-racial no hay paz: las afro-reparaciones en perspectiva hist√≥rico-mundial‚ÄĚ in Afro-reparaciones: memorias de la esclavitud y justicia reparativa para negros; afrocolombianos y raizales; eds. C. Mosquera & L. C. Bracelos; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Littler; J.; 2005. ‚ÄúIntroduction‚ÄĚ in The Politics of Heritage; The Legacies of Race; ed. J. Littler; & R. Naidoo; Routledge; Oxon; New York.


Lowenthal; D.; 2001. ‚ÄúNational museums and historical truth‚ÄĚ in National Museums: negotiating histories: conference proceedings; eds. D. McIntyre & K. Wehner; National Museum of Australia; Canberra.


Lozano; B. R. & Pe√Īaranda; B.; 2007. ‚ÄúMemoria y Reparaci√≥n ¬Ņy de ser mujeres negras qu√©?‚ÄĚ in Afro-reparaciones: memorias de la esclavitud y justicia reparativa para negros; afrocolombianos y raizales; eds. C. Mosquera & L. C. Barcelos; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


MacDonald; S.; 2003. Museums; national; postnational and transcultural identities. Museum and Society;1(1); 1‚Äď16.


Mart√≠n-Barbero; J.; 2002a. ‚ÄúColombia: ausencia de relato y desubicaciones de lo nacional‚ÄĚ in Imaginarios de naci√≥n. Pensar en medio de la tormenta; coord. J. Mart√≠n-Barbero; Ministerio de Cultura; Bogot√°.


Mart√≠n-Barbero; J.; 2002b. Identities: traditions and new communities. Media Culture Society; 24; 621‚Äď641.


McGuigan; J.; 2005. ‚ÄúA community of communities‚ÄĚ in The Politics of Heritage; The Legacies of Race; ed. J. Littler; & R. Naidoo; Routledge; Oxon; New York.


Merlo; J. O.; 1992. ‚ÄúEtnia; regi√≥n y naci√≥n: el fluctuante discurso de la identidad (notas para un debate)‚ÄĚ in Predecir el pasado: ensayos de historia de Colombia; Fundaci√≥n Guberek; Bogot√°.


Mosquera; C.; Barcelos L. C. & Ar√©valo; A. G.; 2007. ‚ÄúIntroducci√≥n‚ÄĚ in Afro-reparaciones: memorias de la esclavitud y justicia reparativa para negros; afrocolombianos y raizales; eds. C. Mosquera & L. C. Barcelos; Facultad de Ciencias Humanas; Centro de Estudios Sociales; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Naidoo; R.; 2005. ‚ÄúNever Mind the Buzzwords: `race¬ī; heritage and the Liberal Agenda‚ÄĚ in The Politics of Heritage; The Legacies of Race; ed. J. Littler; & R. Naidoo; Routledge; Oxon; New York.


Pieterse; J.; 1997. Multiculturalism and Museums: Discourses About Others in the Age of Globalization. Theory; Culture and Society; 14 (4); 123‚Äď146.


Rold√°n; M.; 2000. ‚ÄúMuseo Nacional; fronteras de la identidad y el reto de la globalizaci√≥n‚ÄĚ in Museo; memoria y naci√≥n. Misi√≥n de los museos nacionales para los ciudadanos del futuro; comp. G. S√°nchez & M. E. Wills; Ministerio de Cultura; Bogot√°.


S√°nchez; G.; 2000. ‚ÄúIntroducci√≥n. Museo; memoria y naci√≥n‚ÄĚ in Museo; memoria y naci√≥n. Misi√≥n de los museos nacionales para los ciudadanos del futuro; comp. G. S√°nchez & M. E. Wills; Ministerio de Cultura; Bogot√°.


Sandell; R. 2005. ‚ÄúConstructing and communicating equality. The social agency of museum space‚ÄĚ in Reshaping Museum Space; ed. S. MacLeod; Routledge; New York; London.


Sandell; R. 2007. Museums; Prejudice and the Refraiming of Difference; Routledge; New York/ Oxon.


Sculthorpe; G. 2001.; ‚ÄúExhibiting Indigenous histories in Australian museums‚ÄĚ in National Museums: negotiating histories: conference proceedings; eds. D. McIntyre & K. Wehner; National Museum of Australia; Canberra.


Schwarz; B.; 2005. ‚ÄúAfterword‚ÄĚ in The Politics of Heritage; The Legacies of Race; ed. J. Littler; & R. Naidoo; Routledge; Oxon; New York.


Segura; M.; 1995. Itinerario del Museo Nacional de Colombia 1823‚Äď1994; Instituto Colombiano de Cultura; Museo Nacional de Colombia; Bogot√°.


Sep√ļlveda dos Santos; M.; 2003. Museums without a Past: The Brazilian Case. International Journal of Cultural Studies; 6; 180‚Äď201.


Stevens; M.; 2007. Museums; minorities and recognition: memories of North Africa in contemporary France. Museum and Society 5(1); 29‚Äď43.


Thompson; A.; 2001. Nations; national identities and human agency: putting people back into nations. Sociological Review; 49 (1); 18‚Äď31.


Uberoi; V.; 2007. Social Unity in Britain. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies; 33(1); 141‚Äď157.


Walzer; M.; 1997. ‚ÄúLa pol√≠tica de la diferencia. La estatalidad y la tolerancia en un mundo multicultural‚ÄĚ in La moral del nacionalismo; vol 2; Gedisa; Barcelona. [trans. Tom√°s Fern√°ndez and Beatriz Eguibar].


Wills; M. E.; 2000. ‚ÄúDe la naci√≥n cat√≥lica a la naci√≥n multicultural: rupturas y desaf√≠os‚ÄĚ in Museo; memoria y naci√≥n. Misi√≥n de los museos nacionales para los ciudadanos del futuro; comp. G. S√°nchez & M. E. Wills; Ministerio de Cultura; Bogot√°.


Zambrano; C. V.; 2006. Ejes políticos de la diversidad cultural; Siglo del Hombre Editores; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; Bogotá.

Comparing: National Museums; Territories; Nation-Building and Change. NaMu IV; Linköping University; Norrköping; Sweden 18-20 February 2008

Author:
Cristina Lleras
Title:
National Museums and the Legacies of Exclusion. Issues and Challenges Around Change in the 21st Century
Note: the following are taken directly from CrossRef
Citations:
No citations available at the moment


Responsible for this page: Peter Berkesand
Last updated: 2017-02-21